Wine list divided by calories causes consternation

The wine list of US steakhouse chain Morton’s has sparked alarm on social media after it correlated the country from which a wine originates with its caloric content.

While the inclusion of calorie counts on menus is a highly divisive issue, doing so with drinks can be an even thornier affair.

The list, shared on Twitter by Mike Ratcliffe, the owner of Stellenbosch’s Vilafonté winery, ranked the wines of different nations by the supposed calories found in a 75 centilitre bottle. The figures on the page shared by Ratfcliffe ranged from 600kcals for Spanish, Portuguese and South African reds (one of which was Vilafonte’s 2019 Seriously Old Dirt), to 610kcals for Antipodean Shiraz and Cabernet Sauvignon.

There is some logic to the notion of geography influencing calorie count. Generally speaking, hotter climates will produce grapes with more sugar, and therefore more alcohol during fermentation, resulting in slightly more caloric wines (each gram of alcohol adds about 7kcals). Residual sugar must also be taken into account.

In a piece for specialist club and retailer The Wine Society, Caroline Gilby MW shared that whereas a 175ml glass of a 12% ABV dry wine (red or white) might clock in at 147kcals (630kcals for a bottle), the equivalent serving of a 14% ABV wine would be approzimately 175kcals (750kcals for a bottle). This suggests that the Morton’s figures may be too low across the board.

However, countries can contain a number of climatic zones, and are capable of producing wines in a multitude of styles that clock in at a range of ABVs, then vintage variation has to be considered. Therefore, homogenising an entire country’s viticultural output by ascribing a single caloric value to its wines can be problematic. As one reply to the original tweet stated: “So all 15 South American bottles have the exact same amount of calories?”

Though most winemakers do not publicise the calories in their products, it can be assumed, for example, that there will be some difference between the 15% ABV 2018 Montes Purple Angel and the 13% ABV 2018 Zuccardi The Amphora Project Malbec, yet the list suggests that both will be exactly 605kcals. Likewise, the Familia Torres Salmos 2017 is approximately 14% ABV, and yet is deemed by the list to be less caloric (albeit marginally) than wines of a similar alcohol content further down the list.

Wine writer Jamie Goode blasted the list’s structuring: “What a stupid idea and not based on reality”.

WLC has reached out to Morton’s to ascertain how it arrived at the caloric figure for each country.

Perhaps, calories should be scrubbed from wine lists altogether, as one commenter expressed it: “Can’t decide which is more bizarre – the notion that calories would be uniform by nation, or the notion that their target customer is worried about calories on a Morton’s occasion.”

Morton’s is not the first steakhouse wine list to spark debate on social media – the unconventional nature of that of Flat Iron, in London, also attracted attention.

Related reading: What are the lowest-calorie alcoholic drinks?

This article was originally published by the drinks business and has been shared with permission.

Leave your reply

Most Recent Stories

Ketchup cocktail, anyone? Why bartenders are embracing alternative flavours

From Vegemite to Wagyu beef, are bartenders taking cocktail ingredients too far? Eloise Feilden finds out.

Patrick Schmitt MW: We don't drink wine just for intoxication

Patrick Schmitt MW explains that looking at only the public health and intoxication issues of alcohol misses one of the main reasons why we drink it.

How stingy are Brits when it comes to tipping?

The vast majority of British people would not pay a 20% tip at a restaurant, but younger diners are significantly more generous than older ones, according to a recent study.

Restaurant director to stand trial on spiking charge

Vikas Nath, director of the company that owns Michelin-starred Mayfair restaurant Benares, has pleaded not guilty to the charge of attempting to spike a woman's drink at a private members’ club in Mayfair.

Quarter of hospitality businesses run out of money

A quarter of hospitality businesses have no reserves and almost a third only have three months' worth of cash according to an alarming new joint survey by the UK's biggest trade associations representing the sector.

Most Recent Stories

Ketchup cocktail, anyone? Why bartenders are embracing alternative flavours

From Vegemite to Wagyu beef, are bartenders taking cocktail ingredients too far? Eloise Feilden finds out.

Patrick Schmitt MW: We don't drink wine just for intoxication

Patrick Schmitt MW explains that looking at only the public health and intoxication issues of alcohol misses one of the main reasons why we drink it.

How stingy are Brits when it comes to tipping?

The vast majority of British people would not pay a 20% tip at a restaurant, but younger diners are significantly more generous than older ones, according to a recent study.

Restaurant director to stand trial on spiking charge

Vikas Nath, director of the company that owns Michelin-starred Mayfair restaurant Benares, has pleaded not guilty to the charge of attempting to spike a woman's drink at a private members’ club in Mayfair.

Quarter of hospitality businesses run out of money

A quarter of hospitality businesses have no reserves and almost a third only have three months' worth of cash according to an alarming new joint survey by the UK's biggest trade associations representing the sector.